Scrum is easily one of the most well-known and commonly implemented software development frameworks in the world. At its core,
scrum is actually an
Agile framework. However,
scrum is also technically a subset of
scrum adheres to a rather strict set of processes and practices.
In this article we’ll dive deeper into the origins of
scrum, what the framework is in the realm of software development, how it is typically implemented, and a few potential advantages and disadvantages you may experience while using
scrum on your next project, so let’s get started!
What is Scrum?
"scrum" is most commonly used in the sport of rugby football. In rugby, a
scrum is a method of restarting play after a minor rule infringement has occurred, specifically in a situation where no advantage would be gained for the team that obeyed the rules. A
scrum is formed with eight players from each team linking together into three tight rows on each side, before facing one another with heads down and attempting to push the opposing team out of position. The ball is thrown into the
tunnel (the gap under the players), and the as the
scrum begins, both teams attempt to move the ball using their legs and by repositioning themselves, such that the ball emerges behind their team’s formation and can be taken into possession. I’m no expert and this is a very rudimentary explanation compared to the full rules of a
scrum, which are far more in-depth and interesting, but this origin of
scrum from rugby transitions well into the use of the word within software development.
In the January 1986 issue of Harvard Business Review, two professors at Hitotsubashi University in Tokyo Japan, Hirotaka Takeuchi and Ikujiro Nonaka, published an article titled The New New Product Development Game, which emphasizes the importance of speed and flexibility when developing new products. In the article, Takeuchi and Nonaka detail the lessons learned from manufacturing practices, which they refer to as the
"rugby approach," in which the team “tries to go the distance as a unit, passing the ball back and forth.” The article even goes on to explicitly make use of the term
scrum to define these practices of pushing the team forward, which is considered the introduction of the term to modern software and project development.
A few years later, a software developer named Ken Schwaber began implementing the
scrum framework into software development practices within his company. Over the next few decades, the
scrum framework began to take shape, with the publication of books and guides outlining its use, including the definitive book by Schwaber and colleague Jeff Sutherland, The Scrum Guide. As it happens, the Guide provides us with a definition of what
scrum is: “A framework within which people can address complex adaptive problems, while productively and creatively delivering products of the highest possible value.”
The Scrum Theory, Pillars, and Values
The theory of
scrum is focused on being an empirical process: a framework that attempts to gain experienced-based knowledge, then make decisions based on that learned knowledge. To meet that goal,
scrum is founded on three core pillars:
- Transparency: All relevant aspects of the project must be well-defined and visible to everyone on the team that shares in the responsibility for said aspects.
Scrum Artifactsmust be frequently inspected, to measure progress toward
Sprint Goals(both of which we’ll discuss shortly).
- Adaptation: If an inspector decides that an aspect of the project is failing to meet its intended goals, that aspect should be adjusted as quickly as possible.
The Scrum Guide also lays out the five key
- Commitment: Team members individually commit to achieving their team goals, each and every
- Courage: Team members know they have the courage to work through conflict and challenges together so that they can do the right thing.
- Focus: Team members focus exclusively on their team goals and the
Sprint Backlog; there should be no work done other than through their
- Openness: Team members and their stakeholders agree to be transparent about their work and any challenges they face.
- Respect: Team members respect each other to be technically capable and to work with good intent.
scrum artifact is simply a representation of value or work to be completed, which is well-defined and should be transparently visible to all team members. There are three main types of
Product Backlog: This is the
scrumequivalent of a
work in progresslist. The
Product Backlogis simply an ordered list of all items that are (or may be) necessary throughout the entirety of the software development life cycle. The
Backlogacts as the definitive requirements documentation for the project. The
Product Backlogis maintained by the
Sprint Backlog: A
Sprint Backlogis a subset of items from the
Product Backlogthat have been explicitly selected to be part of a
Incrementis the summation of all
Product Backlogitems that were successfully completed during a particular
Sprint, added to the value of all previous
Scrum Team Roles
There are three primary roles within the whole of the
Product Owner: This individual can best be thought of as the project lead or producer, and his or her aim is to maximize the value of the product by ensuring the
Development Teamproduces the best possible work. The
Product Ownerlargely focuses on maintaining the
Development Team: The group of developers that actually produce the work defined in the
Product Backloginto a functional and releasable iteration. The
Development Teamshould be self-organizing and fully independent from the
Scrum Master: Acts as both the referee and coach for the whole team when it comes to the proper use and implementation of
scrumpractices and processes.
Scrum Events and Workflow
Day-to-day activities within the
scrum framework are all based around particular
scrum events. All
events are “time-boxed”, meaning they each have a maximum duration. This helps to ensure that the development life cycle remains constantly adaptive and properly
scrum framework defines five types of events:
Sprint Planning: During this event, the entire team collaborates to define what the
Sprint Goalwill be for the upcoming
Sprint. This is accomplished by answering two simple questions: 1) What work should be accomplished within the next month? 2) How can that work be completed? The
Sprint Planningsession should be kept to a maximum of eight hours per month.
Sprint: The bread and butter of
Sprintis a one-month period in which a potentially releasable iteration is created (commonly referred to as a “Done”). In spite of the name, a
Sprintis not anything like “crunch time.” Instead, a
Sprintis always active: when one
Sprintends, the next immediately begins.
Daily Scrum: Every day, the
Development Teammeets for a maximum of 15 minutes to discuss the planned work for the next day.
Sprint Review: Following the completion of a
Sprint Reviewis an event with a maximum duration of four hours, in which the entire team discusses the
Incrementresults and makes any necessary changes to the
Sprint Retrospective: At a maximum of three hours, the
Sprint Retrospectiveoccurs after the
Sprint Review, but prior to the next
Sprint, and is a meeting for the entire team to decide on potential improvements that can be made general to practices or procedures for the next
Advantages of Scrum
- Allows for Rapid Prototyping: With a maximum of only one month to devote to any particular
scrumallows for rapid coding and development of ideas or components that may be experimental or may even fail, without severe worry or potential downsides.
- Keeps Customers in the Loop: Since
Agileframework and is highly iterative, customers are able to quickly assess progress and provide feedback throughout the entirety of the development life cycle.
- Encourages Consistent Productivity: The daily meetings of
Daily Scrumsare a guaranteed way to get insight from all team members about their progress, so suggestions and guidance can be provided where necessary to keep development on track.
Disadvantages of Scrum
- Abundance of Meetings: Many people, particularly developers trying to maintain that sweet
flowstate, are unlikely to appreciate the need for numerous meetings, particularly the
- Potential Difficulty With Estimations: As with other
Agileframeworks, it’s quite easy to simply jump into a project and begin development without much in the way of planning. While this is often a benefit, it also means that
scrumcan often obfuscate the actual time and monetary costs of a project (or even aspects of said project), often until a few months down the line.
- Requires Lenient Leadership: Since proper
scrumpractices emphasize the importance of separating the management of
Development Teamsfrom roles like
Product Owner, successful implementation of
scrumrequires that managers and leadership are able to trust the
Development Teamand give them the freedom they need to work independently.